
As I mentioned in a recent post, I used to play Warhammer, but fell out of love with it. One of the things that always baffled me, was how players of Games Workshop games had such a love/hate relationship with the company. Whenever something new came out, be it rules or models, there would be an orgy of teeth gnashing and ripping of hair because the new thing broke the game again or was too expensive or…whatever. All this while the same people were on their way to a local shop to buy said new thing that they must have. GW “fans” are unbelievably critical of the company, it’s business practices and its’ games. I’m not saying the criticism is unwarranted, but the fans don’t really act like it.
Contrast this with the players of Privateer Press games. This company could drop a turd in the middle of the road and the fans would find something good to say about it. The shape would be complimented and the location on the road would be perfectly balanced. It is hard to find anyone in the Warmachine/Hordes community that has much bad to say about Privateer Press, its’ games or its’ models. I was reading a blog post last night that showed off some horrific mould lines and gaps in the fit of model pieces. The author thought that the mould lines were not too bad and the gap was pretty good. Let me tell you that those imperfections would have been ok 20 years ago when I started building models, but not now. When I recently ordered a bunch of models to start my Retribution army, I had to order replacement parts from PP three times in the first week due to missing or miscast parts. I read a lot of Warmachine blogs and nobody addresses these issues.
Don’t get me wrong. I would not like to see the flagellation party that GW “fans” engage in, but I think it’s dangerous when people don’t question what is happening and don’t hold companies more accountable. There has to be a balance between appreciating the things a company has done well and calling them out when they are not hitting the mark. The only way companies improve is when their customers demand it. I love Warmachine and Hordes and I think Privateer Press is a great company, but I think they are short changing their customers in some areas. In the future I’ll be pointing these things out. I just wish that others would take off the rose coloured glasses and start talking about both sides of the story.